Difference between revisions of "User talk:WikiMaster"

From XiphWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Exclude Google from everything.)
(comments)
Line 11: Line 11:
  
 
Real suggestions, that don't involve just going and getting the latest kit:
 
Real suggestions, that don't involve just going and getting the latest kit:
 +
 
* All external linking could be disabled (apparently with "$wgUrlProtocols = '$^';"), and offsite links could be limited to what can be expressed as an [[wikipedia:InterWiki|InterWiki]] link.  This is extremely limiting, and requires that somebody be available to add InterWiki sites as necessary, but it doesn't involve an upgrade.  It would also break many existing pages, so these would need to be found and fixed.  Many links could already be turned to InterWiki syntax. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 
* All external linking could be disabled (apparently with "$wgUrlProtocols = '$^';"), and offsite links could be limited to what can be expressed as an [[wikipedia:InterWiki|InterWiki]] link.  This is extremely limiting, and requires that somebody be available to add InterWiki sites as necessary, but it doesn't involve an upgrade.  It would also break many existing pages, so these would need to be found and fixed.  Many links could already be turned to InterWiki syntax. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 +
: [[User:Andrel|Andrel]] 19:13, 6 Nov 2005 (PST): But external linking is an important part of what this wiki is about.  I've put work into [[VorbisStreams]] precisely because it was easy to link to those sites. Anything which requires regular admin intervention is a nonstarter.
 +
 
* Google seems to index previous versions of pages, which means that reverts are only partially useful.  I think the NoIndexHistory point above should be applied to fix that. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 
* Google seems to index previous versions of pages, which means that reverts are only partially useful.  I think the NoIndexHistory point above should be applied to fix that. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 +
 
* Mark offsite links as [[metawikipedia:Anti-spam Features#rel.3Dnofollow_link_attribute|rel="nofollow"]].  That appears to not be the default, here. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 
* Mark offsite links as [[metawikipedia:Anti-spam Features#rel.3Dnofollow_link_attribute|rel="nofollow"]].  That appears to not be the default, here. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 +
 
* If nothing else at all happens, or to cover the short term while somebody gets around to doing something useful, just exclude Google from everything using robots.txt. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 
* If nothing else at all happens, or to cover the short term while somebody gets around to doing something useful, just exclude Google from everything using robots.txt. --[[User:Gumboot|Gumboot]]
 +
: [[User:Andrel|Andrel]] 19:13, 6 Nov 2005 (PST): Wikis lose a tremendous amount of their value if they aren't indexed by the major search services.  The whole point of things like [[VorbisHardware]] or [[VorbisStreams]] is that users doing a search can find them.  Plus the spammers won't know the wiki is no longer being indexed, so it won't stop them.

Revision as of 19:13, 6 November 2005

I don't know where this text goes, so it's going here...

Lists of things to consider:


Real suggestions, that don't involve just going and getting the latest kit:

  • All external linking could be disabled (apparently with "$wgUrlProtocols = '$^';"), and offsite links could be limited to what can be expressed as an InterWiki link. This is extremely limiting, and requires that somebody be available to add InterWiki sites as necessary, but it doesn't involve an upgrade. It would also break many existing pages, so these would need to be found and fixed. Many links could already be turned to InterWiki syntax. --Gumboot
Andrel 19:13, 6 Nov 2005 (PST): But external linking is an important part of what this wiki is about. I've put work into VorbisStreams precisely because it was easy to link to those sites. Anything which requires regular admin intervention is a nonstarter.
  • Google seems to index previous versions of pages, which means that reverts are only partially useful. I think the NoIndexHistory point above should be applied to fix that. --Gumboot
  • If nothing else at all happens, or to cover the short term while somebody gets around to doing something useful, just exclude Google from everything using robots.txt. --Gumboot
Andrel 19:13, 6 Nov 2005 (PST): Wikis lose a tremendous amount of their value if they aren't indexed by the major search services. The whole point of things like VorbisHardware or VorbisStreams is that users doing a search can find them. Plus the spammers won't know the wiki is no longer being indexed, so it won't stop them.